Codeine vs Hydrocodone: Differences, Dangers and Misconceptions

Key Takeaways

• Codeine and hydrocodone are opioids with different potencies and applications for pain management.
• Codeine is less potent, prescribed for mild to moderate pain and can be used as a cough suppressant.
• Hydrocodone is more potent, used for moderate to severe pain and has a higher risk of addiction.
• Both drugs work by binding to opioid receptors in the brain, altering pain perception.
• Side effects of both medications include constipation, nausea and drowsiness, with hydrocodone having a higher potential for serious side effects.
• The legal status of both drugs is tightly regulated, with hydrocodone generally considered a Schedule II drug, indicating a high potential for abuse.
• Public perception of these opioids is influenced by the opioid crisis, with growing concerns over misuse and addiction.
• Regulations and guidelines are in place to balance the benefits of pain management with the risks of addiction.

What is Codeine?

Codeine, a naturally occurring alkaloid, is extracted from the opium poppy Papaver somniferum. First isolated in 1832 by French chemist Pierre-Jean Robiquet, codeine has long been utilized in the medical field for its analgesic and antitussive properties. Codeine functions by acting on the central nervous system, influencing both the brain and spinal cord to reduce pain and suppress cough.

Medical Applications

Medical uses of codeine span various treatments, including managing mild to moderate pain, particularly post-surgical dental pain and alleviating coughs. While there is weak evidence supporting its use in cancer pain management, it is commonly prescribed for its analgesic effects. However, the National Center for Biotechnology Information indicates that codeine is also employed off-label for persistent diarrhea and restless leg syndrome, showcasing its versatility in managing different conditions.

Dangers

Despite its medical benefits, codeine use is not without risks. The drug’s opioid nature means it can be habit-forming and long-term use may impact fertility. It is crucial for codeine to be prescribed cautiously and patients must adhere to medical guidance to mitigate potential adverse effects and dependency risks.

What is Hydrocodone?

Hydrocodone, a semi-synthetic opioid synthesized from codeine, is a potent analgesic used in the management of moderate to severe pain. Patented in 1923, hydrocodone’s efficacy in pain control has been well-documented, particularly when combined with acetaminophen. Hydrocodone’s mechanism of action involves activating opioid receptors in the brain and spinal cord, altering the perception and response to pain.

Medical Applications

Hydrocodone is available in various formulations, including long-acting versions approved for medical use in the United States in 2013. It is indicated for chronic pain management, postoperative pain control and in patients with trauma or cancer-related pain. 

Dangers

Hydrocodone is often used when pain is not adequately managed by non-opioid alternatives or less potent opioids. However, its use is strictly regulated due to its high potential for addiction and misuse.

Codeine Vs Hydrocodone: A Comparative Analysis

Both opioid medications work by altering pain perception, but the choice between them often depends on the nature and intensity of the pain, patient history and potential for side effects and addiction. Studies have indicated that the side effects of opioids, including both codeine and hydrocodone, can lead to significant healthcare costs, not only due to the management of these side effects but also from costs associated with non-compliance and switching medications.

When comparing codeine and hydrocodone directly, it’s crucial to consider the variability in individual responses to these drugs, such as their response to opioid therapy and their risk for addiction. While codeine may be sufficient for certain patients, others may require the stronger analgesic effects of hydrocodone.

Benefits of Codeine vs Hydrocodone

Codeine is considered less potent and is typically prescribed for mild to moderate pain. Hydrocodone, on the other hand, is recognized for its stronger pain-relieving effects but carries a higher risk for addiction and dependence. According to user reviews, codeine has a higher average rating for positive effects compared to hydrocodone. 

This subjective data suggests that some patients may respond better to codeine despite its generally lower potency. In contrast, hydrocodone’s higher potency is reflected in its dosage strengths, ranging from 2.5 mg to 120 mg in extended-release tablets.

Side Effects of Codeine vs Hydrocodone

Codeine can cause constipation, nausea and drowsiness and its effects vary significantly between individuals. Long-term use may lead to mental or physical dependence. Hydrocodone, on the other hand, can cause side effects such as difficulty with bowel movements, mood changes and unusual drowsiness. Some side effects are more serious, such as impaired hearing, very low blood pressure and reduced ability to drive safely.

Opioids like oxycodone and naloxone combinations may offer fewer gastrointestinal side effects compared to traditional opioids, which can be a consideration in reducing side effect-related costs and guiding opioid use from an economic perspective.

Addiction Potential of Codeine vs Hydrocodone

Codeine is a Schedule II drug when used alone, indicating a high potential for misuse and severe dependence. However, it is classified as Schedule III when less than 90 milligrams are combined with other substances, like acetaminophen and Schedule V for cough preparations with less than 200 milligrams of codeine.

Hydrocodone, on the other hand, is typically classified as a Schedule II substance, reflecting its high potential for misuse and risk of severe psychological or physical dependence.  Both codeine and hydrocodone require careful monitoring and responsible use to minimize the risk of addiction.

Legal Status and Regulations Governing Codeine and Hydrocodone

The legal status and regulations surrounding codeine and hydrocodone are part of efforts to mitigate the opioid crisis while ensuring that patients with legitimate needs for pain management have access to effective treatment.

Both drugs are classified as controlled substances due to their potential for misuse and addiction. In the United States, the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) classifies opioids, including codeine and hydrocodone, as Schedule II substances, indicating a high potential for abuse, which may lead to severe psychological or physical dependence.

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has put forth restrictions on their use due to risks of misuse, addiction and respiratory depression, especially in children. The FDA advises against codeine use in children aged 0 to 11 years and has stringent regulations regarding its prescription for pain and cough. FDA Restrictions on Codeine

Codeine Legal Framework and Regulations

In the United States, the FDA has approved codeine for the treatment of pain and cough, though restrictions exist, particularly for children, due to the risk of rapid metabolism leading to severe side effects. The legal classification of codeine ranges from Schedule II to Schedule V under the Controlled Substances Act, depending on the amount of codeine contained in the product and whether it’s combined with other medications.

While codeine is legal when prescribed by a doctor and dispensed by a pharmacy, its over-the-counter availability is limited to certain cough medications. In the workplace, employers must navigate federal laws concerning the use of opioids among employees, ensuring safety and compliance without discrimination against those who use opioids legally, as outlined by the EEOC.

Hydrocodone Legal Framework and Regulations

As a prescription medication, hydrocodone is legally available to patients with a valid prescription, ensuring its use is monitored and controlled. The Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) plays a significant role in regulating the production and distribution of hydrocodone by setting aggregate production quotas (APQs) annually.

Furthermore, the FDA has updated the prescribing information for all opioids, including hydrocodone, to provide additional guidance on their safe use, which is crucial given the ongoing opioid overdose crisis. This information is designed to inform healthcare professionals and patients about the risks of opioids and the importance of proper medication management, as detailed by the FDA.

Public Perception and Misconceptions of Codeine vs Hydrocodone

The opioid epidemic has significantly influenced public perception and misconceptions of prescription drugs like codeine and hydrocodone. Research indicates that the crisis has affected various aspects of society, from healthcare to employment. For instance, the opioid epidemic has been linked to a decline in labor force participation, as some individuals cannot pass drug tests due to prescription drug misuse. 

This highlights a misconception that prescription opioids are safe simply because they are legal and prescribed by healthcare professionals. Studies show that public perceptions of opioids are often shaped by the negative consequences of misuse, such as addiction and overdose.

Public Perception of Codeine

The public perception of codeine is shaped by its acknowledged therapeutic uses as well as its potential for misuse and dependence. Despite its efficacy in treating mild to moderate pain, there is growing concern over the misuse of codeine-containing products, particularly among youth and healthcare students. 

Research indicates that while there is a general awareness of the risks associated with opioid and codeine use, there is still a significant public health challenge in addressing the misuse and dependency issues. Pharmacists’ perspectives have also been sought, revealing concerns over the intentional or unintentional misuse of pharmaceutical opioids, including codeine.

Public Perception of Hydrocodone

A study published in the National Library of Medicine highlights a shift in media narratives that have influenced public views, moving from a permissive attitude towards opioid analgesics to a more cautious approach, acknowledging the risks of addiction. This changing perception underscores the need for balanced policies that address both the medical needs of patients and the potential for misuse and addiction.

Research from the New England Journal of Medicine indicates that while the US public recognizes prescription pain medication addiction as a significant issue, there is hesitancy to classify it as a national emergency. This ambivalence reflects a complex relationship between the recognition of the opioid misuse epidemic’s severity and the response it warrants.

If you or a loved one struggles with drug or alcohol addiction, Orlando Recovery Center is here to help. Our physician-led, evidence-based rehab programs include medical detox, inpatient and outpatient rehab and a full continuum of care in between. Our compassionate team will help you start life fresh with the tools, coping strategies and resources you need to succeed. Don’t wait — contact a Recovery Advocate today to see how we can help.